I probably worked on that thing harder than any other orchestra piece I ever had to play. When I turned on Platoon, there it was.
My review is posted at: I think there is partial validity to some of the points you raise, but also quite a lot of invalidity. As a Marxist I believe in the importance of criticism and self-criticism and am therefore anxious to receive comments such as yours.
Unfortunately, we live in a society that is generally pretty up-tight about giving or receiving criticism from others. This is one of the reasons that we, as a society, are unable to think about most issues very clearly. Truth itself is discovered through struggle, so where there is no struggle there is no truth.
That what this is. I think I simply took that for granted, but I should have made it clearer. Perhaps, in light of your letter, I should go back and add a comment or two at the end, or even add a link to this message which includes your criticisms and my responses.
Probably Oliver Stone opposed the U. Imperialist War Against Vietnam when it was going on, and even when he was himself over there, in that "hell". And he certainly opposed that war when he made this film.
I have no doubt that the film is consciously meant to be opposed to the war. But it is an interesting fact that the actual effect of things is not always quite what people intend. Probably most people will indeed understand the movie as being opposed to the war.
The movie focuses on the way the U. This is why I claimed that it implies that it would not have been wrong for the U. Even if Stone did not intend to imply this, it is implied in any case.
Furthermore, the message of the movie was that it was wrong for the U. It did not bring out the imperialist nature of the war, nor the imperialist nature of the U. It did not directly oppose U. But I still say that the entire thrust of the film is nevertheless in support of an outlook which would justify the U.
The fact that such a thing is impossible in practice is beside the point. It has implications which he himself may be unaware of, and may or may not have intended. Furthermore, the "heads" led by Sgt. To reactionaries like Newt Gingrich, anything mildly liberal is tainted with "socialism" or "Marxism".
We actual Marxists laugh at that sort of simple-minded inter-ruling class red-baiting. I saw little if anything in the movie that could be taken as "anti-capitalist", and certainly nothing at all that could really be considered to be distinctively "Marxist".
You say that the character "King" is constantly commenting on how the rich always keep the poor down. This, I suppose, is a very crude and primitive expression of class consciousness, since it recognizes that there are such things as the rich and the poor.
But who in the world is ignorant of that? However, this is hardly Marxism, or even anti-capitalism in any real sense.Platoon was the first Hollywood film to be written and directed by a veteran of the Vietnam War.
 Platoon won the Academy Award for Best Picture of ; it also won Best Director for Oliver Stone, as well as Best Sound Mixing and Best Film Editing.
Feb 22, · Platoon is a great movie that really knows how to mess with your emotions. It has the feel of a Vietnam movie with all of the drugs and ’60s music, and also the moral conflicts involved. It has the feel of a Vietnam movie with all of the drugs and ’60s music, and also the moral conflicts involved.
Jan 18, · This video is a critical analysis of the film called Platoon () which is about the Vietnam War. Well.. I found this movie quite interesting and distinct as the visual director of the film.
A Critical analysis of The film Platoon. Essay The Vietnam War was on everyone's mind in s and s in our country. It was the center of much of America's troubles during this time, but only the soldier's who fought in that war knew the true madness that was Vietnam.
Oliver Stone began writing.
A critical essay demands students to carry out a thorough analysis of a selected issue or problem to evaluate this issue. This task is an excellent way to check how students can apply their critical thinking and analytical skills.
Essay film platoon summary. Contax g1 g2 comparison essay essay on why women love shopping writing a essay help methodologie philosophie dissertation frozen elsa and anna drawing essay. Saints ap biology essay Critical analysis essay writing.